Does street photography really help the homeless?

A few years back I knew a Big Issue seller called Martin. He always had a kind word, a smile and always wished everyone well. He & I would chat most days. He was ex-military man who had never really come to terms with life on Civvy Street but had found a way to re-establish his own sense of independence by selling the Big Issue. I only knew him for about 3 years before he died suddenly one New Year’s and I often find myself thinking of him this time of year as I know that despite the hardships in his own life, his attitude taught me a valuable lesson for my own.

 

Of all the mobile photographers out there, let's be honest I'm not exactly known for my street photography. Most of my shots are deserted or sparsely populated at best. I bow the skills of @bradpuet and @last_jedi and I have been moved to tears by portraits by more traditional photographers like Don McCullen.

 

So you’re perfectly entitled to ask what gives me any authority to talk about street portraits….. well frankly, nothing. Of all the thousands of shots I have taken, I have only taken a few of strangers in the street and even fewer of those sleeping rough or begging. So these are just my personal opinions. 

 

Homelessness has always been a problem and continues to be as we start 2013. I have been increasingly asking myself why I have shied away from this as a photographic subject. Is it because I'm a coward and don’t want confrontation? Is it because it can feel that when you take a homeless person’s photo, you’re taking something from someone who already has nothing? Is it because it feels more of an invasion of privacy when somebody has none? Is it because showing the reality of homelessness is just a bit too uncomfortable for many? Or is it because every time I have shared a shot of someone homeless or begging, I can’t escape the thought that the photo won’t actually change anything? I've secretly taken the photo, I've given them a handful of change and I've walked on and continued with the rest of my life. 

I think it’s a bit of all of these reasons and more. So you've taken a photo documenting homelessness. So what? It’s nothing new; they’re not the 1st person to have slept rough and sadly won’t be the last. How is taking a photo and publicly sharing a photo of someone whose circumstances denies them any privacy going to do anything …….. and you’re probably thinking what the hell has this got to do with the story about Martin?

 

I never took Martin’s photo. I wish I had – not as some token gesture, pretending that it would change in his or other homeless people’s lives, but a tribute to the change he effected in mine. I suspect that before we can share any lessons in social responsibility, we have to learn those lessons ourselves first. I wonder how many of us have taken a photo of a homeless person without having the common courtesy of finding out their name & spending just a few moments to talk to them? I know I have.

I don’t know what this guy’s name is. He was sleeping, so I did my usual trick – I took the photo, left a small handful of change by him and walked on. I can’t promise that I’ll be sharing more photos of the homeless but one of my New Year’s resolutions is that if ever I do and share them then I will also share that person’s name and as much of their story as they’re willing to share with me.

 

 

 

Views: 66

Tags: AC Artist Editorials

Comment by Tina Rawatta on December 31, 2012 at 9:35am

Wow, that´s a great idea. As often as I hear the story of an homeless in TV or somewhere else, they have a lot to tell. I guess it will be very interesting to get the story behind a picture known! I would like to see or read something like this!

Comment by Rob holland @robholland1908 on December 31, 2012 at 10:20am

Very thought provoking blog. I have not taken photo's of homes people mainly for the reason i dont think its my place to take photos of them. Some may choose that life many do not so who am i to take advantage of that? But i like your resolution and hope that it wil include asking their permission.

Comment by AMPt on December 31, 2012 at 4:49pm

Wow Alex....I second what Rob said.  Very thought provoking.   I've taken pictures of homeless folks, but I don't have the courage to share with anyone.  Pachi Tamer @cachafaz is real big on getting peoples stories and actually doing something to help with his www.one-dollar-dreams.com.

Comment by Alex Lawson on January 1, 2013 at 9:24am

Thanks for your comments Rob & AMPt. I'm glad you found it interesting and thank you for the link to Pachi's work (& asking permission is taken as read).

Comment by aKwamarina @iPhonehipsta on January 1, 2013 at 9:32am
Hi Alex,what a wonderfully well thought out article this is, thank you for sharing your thoughts! I am particularly glad you point out this great lack of privacy that homelessness incurs and which really affects a person on the streets. And this is where stealing an image is actually adding insult to injury! Our treatment of our subject in these cases is often like wanting to show a curiosity or an animal in a zoo! It does not help or bring anything to that person and questions our motives in a big way, as in what are we really trying to say? I have spent a little time with the homeless at Crisis and what I discovered is a deep sense of loneliness which can be helped a little by actually investing a bit of time talking and exchanging and making the person feel human again, things which taking a picture on the fly can never do! I have a very deep sense that we are all only a few degrees away from the street and that we are all somehow guilty for every person who is already there... We can all help, but shooting and running is not the answer!

Comment

You need to be a member of AMPt Community to add comments!

Join AMPt Community

Photo Of The Day

          Linda Jarai (@lindajarai)

Forum

Oggl?

Started by Graeme Roy in 100% Pure Hipstamatic. Last reply by Renee (@rbpixs) 12 hours ago. 5 Replies

I guess a discussion about Oggl is appropriate in the Hipstamatic category, since they are brother aps, or weird cousins or something. Has anybody been trying it out the last couple of weeks?A few quick observations from me, I've been using it all…Continue

vscocam vs afterglow

Started by Jeremy (@jtmoore_) in iPhone. Last reply by Jeremy (@jtmoore_) yesterday. 5 Replies

Has anyone replaced vsco with the ag app? I love vsco but it takes so long to save, the russ filter is close to vsco's number 5 which is my favorite and with a little fade I can get it close. Just curious...Continue

Copyright Issues Using Google for Edits

Started by Erin @lifewithart in iPhone. Last reply by Renee (@rbpixs) on Saturday. 33 Replies

Hi guys,I've been wanting to start a discussion for awhile now about using internet images to photo-bomb, create montages or add elements to your edits. This discussion could go in many directions as there are several things to consider. I'd like to…Continue

What do you like best about Instagram?

Started by Shane (@shanehawkk) in iPhone. Last reply by Renee (@rbpixs) on Friday. 4 Replies

I'm wondering what everyone's opinion on Instagram is. Millions have an account and it's always on people's minds. What makes you like it? What makes you keep on using it?I personally love taking pictures of things around my area of the world and…Continue

Badge

Loading…

© 2013   Created by AMPt.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service